Counter ‘audit culture’: but be sure to get the message right

This was the theme of an event at IDS organised by the PPSC team recently. The participants were concerned about the increasing emphasis on measurable results, which they felt was sometimes at the cost of focusing on ‘social transformation’. According to them, the problem is

Eyben says there are many reasons for the new funding environment which, she argues, fails to recognise the complexity of development and risks losing the voices and knowledge of local actors.

These include supporters’ and taxpayers’ lack of appetite for complex messages; increased pressure for quick ‘wins’ to demonstrate that aid works; and a belief that challenges such as high levels of maternal mortality in many developing countries are solely technical problems for which straight-forward technical solutions can be found.

The group identified the following as the way forward – 
·   Building ‘counter-narratives’ that emphasise accountability to those for whom international aid exists.
·   Developing innovative communication channels in order to better communicate with the public the complex nature of development.
·   Developing different methods of reporting, so that the requirement for aggregated numbers at Northern policy level captures the character of programming in complex development contexts.
·   Collaborating with people working for change inside donor agencies.
·   Re-claiming the term ‘value for money’.
·   Enhancing organisational learning and reflective practice to nurture out-of-the-box thinking and approaches.
·   Scrutinising the role of big business in development aid and its impact on discourse, quality and accountability.
Working in the measurement industry, I can see how this can horribly go wrong. Is the PPSC advocating a return to the time when development interventions were primarily ideology-driven, with results being secondary? I do not think so. What they are pushing back against, is the tendency of aid agencies aiming for what is easily measurable and in turn, ignoring programs that cannot be measured as easily. Worse still, they may be ignoring sectors that don’t lend themselves to easy evaluations, such as justice systems or taxation. 
I wonder if the challenge should not be upon us to come up with a more versatile tool-kit of evaluation methods? We cannot be method-driven, neither in research not in implementation – and  that itself is not a new idea. But with events such as this, that push back on measurement, one needs to be absolutely sure the message doesn’t get muddled in the rhetoric. 
Advertisements

2 Replies to “Counter ‘audit culture’: but be sure to get the message right”

  1. Hi Suvojit,
    I have just seen your blog. It's great that you are interested in this.

    I agree with you that we have to make sure that we are communicating clearly our concerns and don't get in a muddle with the rhetoric. What it is important to recognise however is that at the moment the demands of inapppropriate ex-ante reporting requirements are leading many organisations to be pretending to comply while actually resisting. This seriously undermines transparency and accountability.

    r.eyben@ids.ac.uk

    Like

  2. Dear Ros,

    Thanks for your comment. I agree that inappropriate reporting requirements disrupt lines of accountability – making it flow primarily upwards, rather than downwards.

    Implementing organisations “pretending” to comply is not ideal for anyone in the system. However, one probably needs to work on all the actors in the system so indicators and targets that actually matter are developed bottom-up; implementers take monitoring and learning goals seriously and use data in their work; and donors and researchers acknowledge the limits of what can be measured.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s